The Launch Debrief: what worked, what bombed, what we're never doing again

Reader,

We closed the doors to CopyTribe 8.0 with 58 talented humans in 2 parallel cohorts! 🎉

Here’s our launch post-mortem — AKA the flops, wins, and lessons learned selling a $6.5K copywriting certification program…in 2025.
(If that’s not daunting, I don’t know what is. 😁)

(Heads-up: this is a 6-min read.)

#1 — This year, people were worried about JOBS.

The economy is bad right now. So many business owners across every industry are reporting slower years, lower revenue, a more challenging climate.

The online course industry in particular is hurting. We've seen this across courses in every vertical. People have less discretionary income, and they're much more wary when investing in professional development.

To make things even tougher: you're not guaranteed a cushy position the minute you graduate CopyTribe. If you're in a good location and willing to work more hours, you’re at an advantage. And there are other factors that can help. But breaking into the marketing industry takes work, and most people will have to hustle and network and put themselves out there to get their first job.

Enrollment was lower than previous years, as we expected.

But it was interesting to see this shift reflected in the emails coming into our inbox.
Compared to last year, we got significantly fewer questions about price.

Instead, people were asking about the job market.
“Will I be able to find clients?”
“Will I be able to find a job?”
“What’s the market like?”

It was the external market uncertainty that had them hesitating this year.

This tells me two things:

Thanks to 7+ years of running CopyTribe, we’ve developed a strong brand reputation. People know this program offers an exceptional educational experience.
We need to continue addressing market concerns head-on in our messaging (with honesty and transparency!) — because that's what's really holding people back.

#2 — High-ticket products have loooong sales cycles.

Quite a few CT8 members first heard about CopyTribe 3, 5, even 6 years ago.

And only now — years later — did they join.

(We did have a handful of people who signed up within a month or two of discovering the program. But that's the exception, not the rule.)

Most people need time. They need to marinate with the idea. Build trust with your brand. Watch you deliver value over and over again.

If you're selling something high-ticket, prepare yourself: Keep showing up. Keep overdelivering. Keep building that trust.

The sales come — just not on a get-rich-quick timeline. 😉

#3 — Personal responses (especially Looms) are gold.

Once again, people loved getting personal Loom videos in response to their questions.

I could have typed out an email. It would have been faster.

But taking 5-10 minutes to record a video — where they could hear my voice and feel like I was talking directly to them — made all the difference.

Several people told us the video response was what tipped them over the edge to enroll.

#4 — Application reviews took HOURS. Still worth it.

We offered an optional, in-depth application for anyone unsure if CopyTribe was right for them.

People submitted writing samples and spent 30-60 minutes answering thought-provoking questions.

And then I personally spent hours — 6.5 total — reviewing every single one and sending personalized feedback.

Was it a significant time investment during an already-intense launch? Yes.

Was it worth it? Absolutely.

We want only good fits inside CopyTribe. We turned several people away.
This process helped us (and them) get crystal clear on whether the program was a fit.

The result: confident members who know they're in the right place. 💥

#5 — The Business Owner track was a hit.

For years, business owners have reached out asking if CopyTribe could work for them.
This year, we crafted a track just for them.

We have 16 members in the Business Owner track!

I’m excited about the win-win:

Founders learn marketing so they can direct their own marketing more effectively and confidently (and avoid wasted marketing dollars).
CopyTribers get more networking opportunities.

Lesson: If you have a valuable offer, think out of the box and consider which other audience segments could benefit from it too.

#6 — Fast-action bonus = mid-launch momentum.

We offered a $250 discount plus a bonus pack (The Work-Life Balance masterclass and Personal Portfolio Review) for people who enrolled by Saturday night.

Here's the breakdown of daily signups:

Bonus fun fact: You can predict the number of sales that will take place on the final day of a launch. It’s almost always ***double*** *the amount of the first day.*

#7 — The downsell worked...for the right segment.

We segmented our list carefully when offering the downsell (CopyStarter).

And the results confirmed what we suspected:

For one segment, it was a great fit. They engaged with the emails and bought.
For another segment, it was totally wrong. Crickets. 🦗🦗🦗

Lesson: Segmenting is worth it because now we have clarity on what we need to do differently.

#8 — The quiz was worth every minute.

Remember that marketing quiz we launched before CT8 opened?

Here's what it did for us:

Brought in 730+ new subscribers — AFTER launch-induced unsubscribes.
Delivered 6 CT8 members. Even if just ONE person had enrolled from the quiz, the time investment would have been worth it.

But beyond the numbers, people loved it. Here's what one quiz-taker said:

If you haven't taken the quiz yet, *try it now. It's fun, insightful, and you might discover something about your skills you didn't realize.*

#9 — Happy customers = strong referral system.

42% of CT8 members came through word-of-mouth.
Friends told friends. Alumni told neighbors. People vouched for us because we delivered.

Overdelivering can feel like it's eating up your resources in the moment.

But down the line it almost always pays off.

Lesson: Your best marketing isn't your ads or your emails. It's your satisfied customers telling everyone they know. Invest there first.

#10 — Launching = losing subscribers. It's normal.

You will lose subscribers during a launch. Period.

But how much bleeding is normal?

The consensus:

Average unsubscribe rate for a typical campaign is around 0.1% to 0.5%.
(Our benchmark is under 0.2%.)
Launch period unsubscribe rates are generally 2-3% per email.
A consistent rate of above 1.5% needs attention.

This year, we sent a heads-up email before the launch: “We're about to send some sales emails. If you're not interested, opt out now.”

It helped. But next time, we might segment even more carefully — sending fewer emails to our whole list and more to warmer segments who've shown interest.

Lesson: Launching means some people will leave. That's okay.
The ones who stay are your people. 😊

2 things we're fixing for next time:

#1 — Rebuild the Webflow page from scratch.

Our sales page looks beautiful. It converts well.
But over years of editing the page, the backend became a hot mess. 🙈

*Do NOT ask Gavriella, my amazing Project Manager, Curriculum Developer, and Webflow Wrangler how much time she spent in Webflow.*

The loading time inside the Editor is PAINFUL. We were this close 🤏 to switching platforms this year, but for technical reasons, stuck it out.

Next year, we're rebuilding from scratch. No more wrestling with a sluggish editor during crunch time.

#2 — November launches = May prep.

This was the first year we launched in November. We learned that if we're going to launch in November, we need to start prep work in May.

Sounds early. But here's what happened:

August = summer schedules, minimal work time
September = focused on the quiz and list-building
October = holidays, minimal work time
November = straight into launch with a tight timeline

Next time, we'll either pick a different month or dedicate way more prep time.

👉 Most importantly, none of this would have worked without my ridiculously talented team who handled everything from marketing strategy to copywriting, tech setup to last-minute page edits. So grateful for you guys! 🙏

Let’s sum ‘er up:

Messaging needs to address market concerns more than in the past.
High-ticket products have long sales cycles.
Personal video replies are gold.
Detailed application reviews are 100% worthwhile.
The Business Owner track was a hit.
The fast-action bonus contributed nicely to mid-launch momentum.
Segment! The downsell was only a fit for one audience.
The quiz was very, very worthwhile. Not to mention fun. 😁
Happy customers = automatic referral system. Keep overdelivering.
Launching = losing subscribers.
NOT worth wrangling with Webflow again. Build from scratch.
November launch prep begins in May.

Which takeaway was most interesting to you?

Hit reply — I read every email.

P.S. — If you took the quiz, share it with a friend who's curious about marketing.
People are finding it genuinely helpful (and a little addictive 😉).

Liked this email? Forward to a friend!
They can sneak in this back door to get their own emails.

You got this email because you bought a product, enjoyed a free resource, attended a training,
or wanted my insights in your inbox.

No more stuff from me? Unsubscribe
(I won't take it personally. I won't take it personally. I WON'T TAKE IT PERSONALLY!)
^^^ If I say it enough times, I'll convince myself.

777 Brickell Avenue, Miami, Florida 33131

Michal Eisik

The Launch Debrief: what worked, what bombed, what we're never doing again

[Dalia’s story] Plot twist

Why these 3 business owners joined ScaleTribe.

Which ScaleTribe track is right for {{ subscriber.first_name | capitalize }} {{ subscriber.last_name | capitalize }}? (if any)